NDISWRAPPER on the livecd

brainiac_ghost · n00b Joined: 19 Sep 2004 Posts: 40

seeing as all bugs about this get closed, i am making a poll about whether you think ndiswrapper should be on the livecd, i will make this fair, listing points for and against:
for:

only a 200k binary, that needs to be compiled for a specific kernel

would help lots of people, and you don't need to use it if you don't want it

not difficult to add

networkless install

need to download drivers onto a USB stick anyway, so you may as well stick ndiswrapper on the usb stick too

amne · Posted: Sun Mar 12, 2006 11:41 am Post subject:

The reasons for not adding ndiswrapper are described quite clearly in Bug 69707.

Out of interest:
1) Why would someone buy something that works with ndsiwrapper only?
2) Assuming you have such a device, sure you may want to use it once Gentoo is set up. But why not simply use good old wired ethernet for installing? Works out of the box, puts no extra work on Releng, no extra playing around with docache, change live cds etc.
_________________
Dinosaur week! (Ok, this thread is so last week)

brainiac_ghost · n00b Joined: 19 Sep 2004 Posts: 40

well, i got a wlan card with GPL drivers, but they aren't on the livecd either, and you don't have to mess around with docache, floppy or usb stick, and it isn't that much extra strain, it is adding one word to a specfile

amne · Posted: Sun Mar 12, 2006 12:03 pm Post subject:

aidanjt · Posted: Sun Mar 12, 2006 1:32 pm Post subject:

Why not simpily use wired ethernet always.. wireless makes token ring look good.

brainiac_ghost · n00b Joined: 19 Sep 2004 Posts: 40

my pc is in a totally different room, i can't move it (not enough room in the room that the router is), and it is just hassle and annoyence to get wires around my house

aidanjt · Posted: Sun Mar 12, 2006 1:43 pm Post subject:

is it that hard to drill a hole in the roof and feed a cable through?

brainiac_ghost · n00b Joined: 19 Sep 2004 Posts: 40

NeddySeagoon · Posted: Sun Mar 12, 2006 2:31 pm Post subject:

brainiac_ghost,

You can add ndiswrapper to a networkless install the same way as you add the XP drivers it needs for your hardware.
Maybe there is an argument for putting the following steps in the manual, if they are not there already.

1. Do networkless install
2. emerge ndiswrapper -pf
Make a list of the URLs it spits out

Bad Penguin · Guru Joined: 18 Aug 2004 Posts: 507

Raftysworld · Posted: Sun Mar 12, 2006 10:48 pm Post subject:

Ugh...

Shadow Skill · Veteran Joined: 04 Dec 2004 Posts: 1023

I dont see why including ndiswrapper would be any real problem. Ndiswrapper itself will probably not need much if any testing and retrieving functioning windows drivers for use with Ndiswrapper is something people using Ndiswrapper are probably aware of. If not a quick blurb in the install guide should be more than sufficient.
_________________
Ware wa mutekinari.
Wa ga kage waza ni kanau mono nashi.
Wa ga ichigeki wa mutekinari.

"First there was nothing, so the lord gave us light. There was still nothing, but at least you could see it."

aidanjt · Posted: Mon Mar 13, 2006 12:34 am Post subject:

pilla · Posted: Mon Mar 13, 2006 12:54 am Post subject:

Why don't you use the ethernet just to get it to the point that you can install ndiswrapper? It shouldn't be a big deal to have your notebook in another room for a day or so. If you can't do it, please thing two times before asking developers to expend time on it if you can't waste yours.

It's ok to have devices that can only work with proprietary drivers, but you cannot blame Gentoo for not having support out of the livecd for it. Blame the maufacturer that does not ship a decent driver or at least something that we can put in the livecd without problems with licenses.
_________________
"I'm just very selective about the reality I choose to accept." -- Calvin

slonocode · Apprentice Joined: 03 Jun 2002 Posts: 273

I've never used ndiswrapper. Is it common for livecd's to exlcude it?

HydroSan · Posted: Mon Mar 13, 2006 1:49 am Post subject:

What I want to know is why are all the devs so defensive about adding ndiswrapper to the LiveCD.

It doesn't make any sense. Seriously. Some hardware ISN'T SUPPORTED BY LINUX. Get the fuck over it. Some are supported through ndiswrapper. Are you going to cut people who don't have the cash to "buy the proper hardware" out, simply because you don't feel as though ndiswrapper is "necessary"?

Hell, I don't even use wireless and I think ndiswrapper would be good to have on a LiveCD.

EDIT: I know how ndiswrapper works. I know shipping the binary drivers would be impossible. But at the very least having the ability to USE binary drivers would be good.
_________________
I was a Gangster for Capitalism, by Major General Smedley Butler.

Server status: Currently down, being replaced with fresh install - 20% completed.

pilla · Posted: Mon Mar 13, 2006 2:00 am Post subject:

slycordinator · Advocate Joined: 31 Jan 2004 Posts: 3065 Location: Korea

If you absolutely need ndiswrapper, it's supported in knoppix (since version 3.7 I believe).

Though I'm not sure if it's in knoppix64.

Shadow Skill · Veteran Joined: 04 Dec 2004 Posts: 1023

Oh just put the damned thing on the cd or dvd and say this method is not actually supported instead of advocating that people be completely screwed if you can't find a developer or other volunteer to test it. [which I find very hard to believe even for gentoo.] I can think of situations where one has proximity to the router or modem but A the nic is not detected by the livecd and B there simply are not enough free cables around, or C the onboard nic/modem is shot for one reason or another. Don't say something like that does not happen because I have had nic cards completely die on me, I also managed to somehow break my pcmcia slot thereby rendering wireless connectivity impossible on my current laptop. [Either my brother or myself unknowingly forced the wireless card too far into the port thereby splitting the connector in half.]

While Knoppix is also an idea I really have found it to be somewhat finiky about whether it wanted to work properly or not.

If you setup your wireless properly no one is going to be able to spy on you from across the street so that is not much of a point.

What could be sooo creepy about a netgear wireless card?

While I don't personally need this thing to actually get Gentoo or any other system installed the idea of being able to setup the wireless connectivity during the installation process before I actually get to the installing part is definetly appealing since it would allow me to liberate the cable I would normally use for such things plug it into my playstation and play a game or two while I wait for the system to finish building with the new model I want to get a month or so from now.

To the original poster perhaps you could create a custom live cd with ndiswrapper on it so as to avoid this sort of annoyance in the future until such time as the Gentoo developers decide to include this on the live cd.
_________________
Ware wa mutekinari.
Wa ga kage waza ni kanau mono nashi.
Wa ga ichigeki wa mutekinari.

"First there was nothing, so the lord gave us light. There was still nothing, but at least you could see it."

Bad Penguin · Guru Joined: 18 Aug 2004 Posts: 507

brainiac_ghost · n00b Joined: 19 Sep 2004 Posts: 40

hell, i would test it if given the chance, it isn't too difficult to do either, just add ndiswrapper to the specfile, and in the handbook say that it is not supported

ydleiF · Posted: Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:13 pm Post subject: Against

I'm against it for the simple reason that I want manufacturers to support linux directly, properly, with drivers, instead of being able to use the excuse "use windows drivers with ndiswrapper". The more linux distros support ndiswrapper, the less of a reason manufacturers have to support Linux.

Thanks for setting the poll up.

Bad Penguin · Guru Joined: 18 Aug 2004 Posts: 507

ydleiF · Posted: Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:31 pm Post subject:

I think it is very black and white. Free software is something I am dedicated to, and this falls clearly within that realm. You make good points, I have been in the same situation. Which is why I ask about their return policy, and deal with it accordingly. Unfortunately this is part of using Linux these days, at times.

Getting proper Linux support is far more important to me than any of the other factors, you can come up with scenarios all day. I will not endorse supporting, directly or indirectly, manufacturers who want to pretend Linux users do not exist. Full stop.

amne · Posted: Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:40 pm Post subject:

Folks, it's not like we are discussing if Gentoo should support ndiswrapper in general, it's just about the live-CD. If you want to install Gentoo on a system that has a device requiring ndiswrapper you can
a) install using hard-wired ethernet, even if you have to relocate your notebook to another room for 2 hours or so. As soon you're done with the install you can emerge ndiswrapper and you are done.
b) use any other live CD that supports ndiswrapper.
c) build your own live CD with catalyst.

The releng appearently has no interest in supporting ndiswrapper on the live CDs for some reasons as license issues and/or not willing to add another package that breaks stuff and needs testing while there are plenty of alternatives putting no extra work on Releng that work quite well, too.
_________________
Dinosaur week! (Ok, this thread is so last week)