VLC does not center video and uses "wrong" ratio

SlowMotion · n00b Joined: 26 May 2024 Posts: 37

Seems the problem only occurs if the window size and the video size is not matching.

If the window width is increased, left and right black areas appear (correct).

But when the window high increases the bottom of the video is cropped, the higher the window gets, the more pixels get cropped.

Hint : I am using KDE with X11 as wayland is freezing my desktop.

SlowMotion · n00b Joined: 26 May 2024 Posts: 37

Nobody has an idea ?

lars_the_bear · Guru Joined: 05 Jun 2024 Posts: 526

I have no idea but, for what it's worth, I'm seeing the same thing, I think -- an area cropped off the bottom of the image when the image aspect ratio doesn't match the screen aspect ratio.

I just took this to be a bug in VLC. There are enough alternatives to VLC that I haven't worried much about it, to be honest. The same files play fine with mplayer.

BR, Lars.

SlowMotion · n00b Joined: 26 May 2024 Posts: 37

OK so at least it is not an error on my system

Where can I report such problems on vlc if it is possibly ONLY occuring in gentoo ?

Because in debian (a little bit older) I didn't have this problem :/

Hu · Administrator Joined: 06 Mar 2007 Posts: 22718

Debian almost certainly is using an older version of VLC. Debian is known for being behind. The first question I would ask is whether this is Gentoo-specific or version-specific.

I will also note that nowhere in this thread do I see mention of what version of vlc is impacted. While that could be inferred from the current stable keywords, this thread will outlast those keywords, so it would be helpful to mention the version(s) of vlc in which the problem was observed.

Is there a free-to-distribute video file which exhibits the problem? That would let other users test for whether the problem is observed broadly.

SlowMotion · n00b Joined: 26 May 2024 Posts: 37

Sorry, I had the versions in the first draft of this ticket.

Gentoo 3.0.21
Debian (my version) 3.0.10

I had it yet with ALL videos I tried.

I just searched on gentoo system and found this file, possibly you also have this :

/usr/share/doc/docutils-0.21.2/html/docs/user/rst/images/pens.mp4

If someone tells me how to upload images for this forum, I can also show screens of the problem.

Hu · Administrator Joined: 06 Mar 2007 Posts: 22718

Yes, I have that file. You cannot upload images to the forum. You can link to images hosted elsewhere.

SlowMotion · n00b Joined: 26 May 2024 Posts: 37

In the meantime the bug got fixed (I assume by vlc)

So this can get closed